After the Election, ATF’s NFA Promise Is Even Shakier

Suppressor and paperwork on a desk

ATF’s October decision not to enforce major National Firearms Act registration rules is still just a policy. After the election, Texas Gun Rights President Chris McNutt told The Dispute Index the only lasting answer is repeal.

The National Firearms Act was not repealed on October 9. It was not repealed on November 3 either.

On November 18, The Dispute Index published a statement from Texas Gun Rights President Chris McNutt on ATF’s nationwide nonenforcement policy for specified NFA registration and approval requirements. The election, he said, did not make that promise any more durable.

“Short of repeal, no administrative promise is lasting. That was true before November 3 and it’s true now,” McNutt said.

“A nonenforcement policy can be reversed by the next administration with the stroke of a pen, and the federal government’s NFA registry remains intact. ATF’s own guidance now admits that enforcement could resume and that gun owners who relied on the government’s promises have no automatic grandfather protection.”

“The election doesn’t change our position. Gun owners shouldn’t have to wonder whether their government will come back for them in 2029.”

That is the same warning Texas Gun Rights issued when the policy was announced, and again when the first manufacturers started selling into it. The election made the point harder to dodge.

The Law Is Still on the Books

On October 9, ATF said it would stop enforcing major NFA registration, approval, and tax-stamp requirements for suppressors, short-barreled rifles, short-barreled shotguns, and certain other firearms.

As Texas Gun Rights wrote on October 12, that announcement did not change federal law. It announced that the agency would stop enforcing it.

The underlying statutes and criminal penalties are still on the books. The court’s August 5 judgment in Silencer Shop Foundation v. ATF, consolidated with Jensen v. ATF, barred enforcement against defined plaintiffs and, where applicable, their members and customers.

The nationwide policy that followed is a separate decision by the Justice Department. A future administration can rescind it.

ATF’s own guidance, in a section Texas Gun Rights has already quoted under the heading “Future Risk,” acknowledges that enforcement could resume if the legal circumstances change or a future Justice Department withdraws the policy.

It also says federal law provides no automatic grandfather protection for firearms acquired without registration, and generally does not allow them to be registered after the fact. An Attorney General could offer a temporary amnesty. Nothing requires one.

On November 2, Texas Gun Rights reported that Palmetto State Armory had begun selling qualifying short-barreled rifles in 17 states, including Texas, without the traditional ATF Form 4 process.

That is real relief for gun owners. It is also a marketplace moving under a policy that can be pulled back, while the registration law sits unchanged.

This is not legal advice. Check current federal, state, and local law, and your dealer’s requirements, before you buy.

Repeal Is the Only Lasting Fix

Congress had a chance to finish this in 2025, when it zeroed out the $200 making and transfer tax on suppressors and certain short-barreled firearms and left the registration framework standing.

Texas Gun Rights refused to treat that tax cut as the mission accomplished. Temporary nonenforcement is the sequel to that decision, not a substitute for it.

McNutt told The Dispute Index what a reversal would mean, and what Congress still has to do.

“At an absolute minimum, Congress should enact permanent statutory protections ensuring that Americans who relied in good faith on ATF’s guidance cannot face prosecution, confiscation, or forced registration simply because Washington reverses course,” he said.

“But protecting gun owners from a future betrayal is not the same as restoring their constitutional rights. Congress should repeal these NFA provisions and destroy the registry records. And the courts should settle this on Second Amendment grounds, not a tax technicality.”

“Prosecuting Americans who followed the government’s own published guidance wouldn’t make anyone safer,” McNutt said. “These suppressor and short-barreled rifle owners did nothing wrong.”

“Telling people they can rely on a policy and then charging them as felons for relying on it isn’t public safety. It’s a government-created trap. The government shouldn’t get to turn law-abiding Americans into federal felons simply because it changed its mind. No compromise.”

A promise not to enforce a gun-control law is not the same as repealing it. Gun owners who follow today’s guidance should not have to wonder whether a different administration will come back for them in 2029.

Congress can end that trap. Until it does, the NFA is not dead.

Chip in to Texas Gun Rights to finish the fight against the National Firearms Act, and to keep the pressure on Congress to repeal it and destroy the registry.

 

Texas Gun Rights uses AI tools to help research and prepare our articles. Every piece is reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by our team through a no-compromise Second Amendment lens. Read our Editorial Standards
Subscription Form

Subscribe to TXGR Alerts!

Never miss a beat from Texas Gun Rights. Get the latest news and alerts on the Second Amendment. TXGR will never sell or rent your personal information!

By providing your information and checking this box, you are consenting to receive communications in the form of phone calls, text messages or emails, including autodialed and automated calls and texts, to that number from Texas Gun Rights. Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Text HELP for help. Text STOP to unsubscribe from text communications. You can view our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy at the bottom of every page.

More Posts

Sign up

Signup Form

By checking this box and providing your phone number, you consent to receive recurring text alerts from Texas Gun Rights, including autodialed messages. Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Text HELP for help. Text STOP to unsubscribe. Consent is not required to sign up for email alerts. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

This will close in 0 seconds

Sign Up