SCOTUS Rules Against Second Amendment In U.S. V. Rahimi

June 21, 2024 

We can’t win ’em all.

In a contentious ruling, the Supreme Court decided that individuals deemed by a court to pose a credible threat to the safety of another can be temporarily disarmed.

This decision upholds the federal statute 18 U.S.C. §922(g)(8), which prohibits firearm possession for those under domestic violence restraining orders, marking a significant move towards the potential for abuse under “red flag” gun confiscation laws.

Zackey Rahimi challenged the statute after being indicted for possessing a firearm while under a domestic violence restraining order.

Initially, the Fifth Circuit ruled in Rahimi’s favor, questioning whether the statute aligned with historical firearm regulations as required by the Supreme Court’s decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen.

Chief Justice Roberts, writing for the majority, emphasized the historical precedent of disarming individuals who pose a threat to public safety. The Court held that while the Second Amendment secures the right to keep and bear arms, this right is not unlimited and allows for regulations that prevent potential violence.

The ruling clarified that modern laws must align with historical practices of firearm regulation.

Justice Thomas stood alone in dissent, arguing that the majority failed to correctly apply the text, history, and tradition of the Second Amendment. He contended that the historical precedents cited did not justify the broad restrictions imposed by §922(g)(8).

This ruling reaffirms the government’s perceived ability to enforce firearm regulations aimed at preventing violence, but it also raises concerns about overreach and the misuse of restraining orders.

Chris McNutt, President of Texas Gun Rights, voiced strong opposition to the ruling, highlighting its potential misuse:

“Let me be clear, Rahimi is a scumbag. I firmly believe that if someone is dangerous, you should try them, convict them and, if guilty, lock them up and throw away the key. Anything less is a blatant disgrace. But this ruling is an assault on our rights protected by the Fifth and Second Amendment by disarming people who haven’t committed a crime.”

The Supreme Court’s decision sets a precedent for how future challenges to firearm regulations might be handled, particularly in dealing with “red flag” gun confiscation laws, where firearms can be seized without due process of the law, and without a crime being committed.

A bill to prohibit these types of laws in Texas is a legislative priority for Texas Gun Rights and was filed by Rep. Briscoe Cain during 88th legislative session (HB 1894), but the measure died after Republicans Justin Holland and Sam Harless walked out of a critical committee vote, empowering Democrats to kill the bill.

Texas Gun Rights uses AI tools to help research and prepare our articles. Every piece is reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by our team through a no-compromise Second Amendment lens. Read our Editorial Standards
Subscription Form

Subscribe to TXGR Alerts!

Never miss a beat from Texas Gun Rights. Get the latest news and alerts on the Second Amendment. TXGR will never sell or rent your personal information!

By providing your information and checking this box, you are consenting to receive communications in the form of phone calls, text messages or emails, including autodialed and automated calls and texts, to that number from Texas Gun Rights. Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Text HELP for help. Text STOP to unsubscribe from text communications. You can view our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy at the bottom of every page.

More Posts

Sign up

Signup Form

By checking this box and providing your phone number, you consent to receive recurring text alerts from Texas Gun Rights, including autodialed messages. Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Text HELP for help. Text STOP to unsubscribe. Consent is not required to sign up for email alerts. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

This will close in 0 seconds

Sign Up