House Chairman: ATF’s 1.4 Billion-Record Gun File Is One Software Switch From a Registry

Illustration of a warehouse aisle lined with banker's boxes on metal shelves. This is not a photograph of the ATF facility in Martinsburg, West Virginia. The Texas Gun Rights seal appears in the upper left.

A House subcommittee heard Wednesday that ATF can turn name search on in a federal file of gun buyers the law says cannot exist. Texas Gun Rights says the answer is still to shred it.

The chairman of a House subcommittee said Wednesday that the difference between ATF’s 1.4 billion-record gun-buyer archive and an illegal national registry “may come down to a software setting that ATF itself controls.”

Federal law already bans that registry. The file is still sitting in Martinsburg, West Virginia. And Jamie Raskin is weeks away from a Judiciary gavel.

The House Oversight Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement, chaired by Rep. Clay Higgins of Louisiana, held its hearing on ATF’s out-of-business records at 1 p.m. Central. No sitting ATF official appeared.

The File Washington Swears Does Not Exist

When a licensed dealer closes without a successor, federal law requires it to ship its Form 4473s and acquisition logs to ATF. A September 24 letter from eight U.S. senators, led by Sen. James Risch of Idaho, says the Martinsburg records “include names, addresses, Social Security numbers, and the specific firearms purchased,” and puts the count at 1,414,088,513, up from roughly 920 million in 2021.

In opening remarks as delivered, Higgins said ATF took in “roughly 6.8 million new records per month” in Fiscal Year 2025 and “keeps them indefinitely.” The agency, he said, claims it follows the federal ban on searching those records “by name or any other personal identifier.”

Then he said the quiet part out loud. When the records are scanned into ATF’s Out of Business Records Imaging System, “a buyer’s name can be captured as searchable data.” Name search, Higgins said, “is a function that ATF has simply ‘turned off’ to remain compliant with federal law. It could just as easily be turned on.”

A government that holds the list can always decide to read it. The Firearm Owners’ Protection Act, at 18 U.S.C. § 926(a), already bars “any system of registration of firearms, firearms owners, or firearms transactions or dispositions.” A billion-plus records in a federal computer, waiting for a switch to be flipped, is a registration system in everything but name.

A 60-Year Clock Is Not a Fix

In May, ATF published a proposed rule, RIN 1140-AA95, to replace indefinite retention with a 20- or 30-year limit. Higgins walked through the fine print. The clocks stack. A record could sit with a dealer for 30 years, then sit with ATF for 30 more. “That is 60 years on file for a law-abiding American’s name, address, and gun purchase data.” Higgins said he is “not necessarily one of those people” who call that a step in the right direction.

Retired ATF official Wally Nelson, who ran the National Tracing Center from 1998 to 2005, backed a 20-year cap and said the digitized records are not searchable by name.

The House already has a bill that would finish the job. H.R. 563, introduced in January 2025 by Rep. Michael Cloud of Texas and cosponsored by Higgins, would stop closing dealers from shipping their records to ATF and would order the agency to destroy the records it already holds, within 90 days of enactment. It has sat in the Judiciary Committee ever since.

Anti-Gun Democrats Came to Defend the Archive

Ranking Member Greg Casar of Texas opened by calling for more gun control: closing what he called background check loopholes, blocking semi-automatic rifles for adults under 21, and a federal extreme risk protection order law. Those are universal gun registration, a semi-auto ban for legal adults, and gun confiscation orders. He said that when Democrats next hold the majority, they will “do everything we can on this committee and in the Congress to save lives.”

Gregory Jackson, a former deputy director of the Biden White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention, testified that out-of-business records completed 52 percent of crime-gun trace requests from 2000 to 2023. He called destroying the file “extremely dangerous” and said it is not a registry because it cannot be searched by a gun owner’s name. A search function that is switched off is still a search function.

Casar then pressed Higgins to abandon H.R. 563, hoping the chairman would “rescind his support” for a bill that would, in Casar’s words, “eliminate this critical law enforcement tool.” Higgins did not drop the bill on the record. He said he supports “the discussion of a 20-year retention of records,” but that “doesn’t include the digitization of records that are turned over by licensed firearms dealers.”

Anti-gun Democrats will not settle for a time limit. They want the list, and they want to add every private sale to it. As Texas Gun Rights reported, Democrats won the House on November 3, and Rep. Jamie Raskin is positioned to chair the Judiciary Committee with background checks on private gun sales near the top of his list. He would inherit the 1.4 billion-record file in Martinsburg.

The archive they deny and the registry they want are the same project.

“The chairman said out loud what ATF has been hiding for years. The only thing between this archive and a searchable national registry is a setting the agency can flip on itself,” said Texas Gun Rights President Chris McNutt. “Republicans still hold the gavel for a few more weeks. If they leave 1.4 billion records sitting in West Virginia for Jamie Raskin, they have failed every gun owner in America. Destroy the records now.”

What Texas Gun Rights Demands

Texas Gun Rights is calling on Congress and the Justice Department to act before January: pass H.R. 563, or otherwise order those out-of-business records destroyed; reject any final rule that restarts the retention clock when records reach ATF; and stop digitizing newly surrendered dealer records immediately.

ATF says the registry doesn’t exist.

Then it has no reason to object when Congress orders it shredded.

Chip in to Texas Gun Rights to fight federal gun registration, from ATF’s West Virginia archive to Raskin’s Judiciary Committee.

 

Texas Gun Rights uses AI tools to help research and prepare our articles. Every piece is reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by our team through a no-compromise Second Amendment lens. Read our Editorial Standards
Subscription Form

Subscribe to TXGR Alerts!

Never miss a beat from Texas Gun Rights. Get the latest news and alerts on the Second Amendment. TXGR will never sell or rent your personal information!

By providing your information and checking this box, you are consenting to receive communications in the form of phone calls, text messages or emails, including autodialed and automated calls and texts, to that number from Texas Gun Rights. Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Text HELP for help. Text STOP to unsubscribe from text communications. You can view our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy at the bottom of every page.

More Posts

Sign up

Signup Form

By checking this box and providing your phone number, you consent to receive recurring text alerts from Texas Gun Rights, including autodialed messages. Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Text HELP for help. Text STOP to unsubscribe. Consent is not required to sign up for email alerts. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

This will close in 0 seconds

Sign Up